Barbell Bench Press vs Dumbbell Bench Press: The Better Exercise

As a beginner deciding on which exercises to do for your chest isn’t easy. With so many different exercises, methods, it can be quite challenging getting started.

Is it a good idea to do both barbell and dumbbell bench press, or is it better to prioritize one?

Barbell bench press is the more traditional approach, with dumbbell bench press requiring more technique. Both exercises are great for the chest with many benefits for each.

In this article we break down Barbell Bench Press vs Dumbbell Bench Press, showing you which exercise is better for your needs.

Whether you are a beginner or an experienced lifter, understanding the nuances of each technique can help you optimize your bench press training and achieve your fitness goals more effectively.

What are the similarities?

The barbell bench press and dumbbell bench press are both popular and effective upper-body strength exercises that primarily target the chest, sharing several similarities:

• Chest Emphasis: Both exercises primarily target the pectoral muscles (chest), making them effective for chest development.
• Compound Movements: Both the barbell and dumbbell bench presses are compound exercises, which means they engage multiple muscle groups. In addition to the chest, they also involve the shoulders and triceps.
• Stability: Both exercises require core and stabilizer muscle engagement to control and stabilize the weights.
• Range of Motion: The range of motion is similar in both exercises, allowing for a full extension of the arms at the top of the lift and a controlled descent of the weights to the chest.
• Strength Building: They are excellent for building upper-body strength and can be used as part of a strength training program.
• Accessory Muscles: In addition to the primary muscles, they work accessory muscles, such as the triceps, anterior deltoids (front shoulders), and upper back muscles.
• Versatility: Both exercises can be adapted for various goals, including strength, hypertrophy (muscle growth), and muscular endurance.

The choice between the two often depends on individual preferences and training goals. Some individuals even incorporate both exercises into their workout routines to take advantage of the unique benefits of each.

What are the differences?

While these exercises have many similarities, they also have some differences, especially in terms of execution.

Here are some of the main differences between the two:

Equipment Used

• Barbell Bench Press: In the barbell bench press, you use a barbell, a long, straight bar with weights loaded onto each end. It’s a single, rigid piece of equipment.
• Dumbbell Bench Press: The dumbbell bench press involves using a pair of dumbbells, each held in one hand. This provides more independence for each arm during the exercise.

Unilateral vs. Bilateral Movement

• Barbell Bench Press: It’s a bilateral exercise, meaning both arms work together. This can sometimes mask strength or muscle imbalances between the two sides.
• Dumbbell Bench Press: It’s a unilateral exercise, as each arm works independently. This can help identify and address imbalances between the left and right sides of the body.

Stability and Balance

• Barbell Bench Press: The barbell provides stability and can make it easier to lift heavier weights. However, it can also limit the range of motion and adaptability to individual body types.
• Dumbbell Bench Press: Dumbbells require more balance and stabilization due to the independence of each arm. They allow for a more natural range of motion and can adapt to a person’s unique anatomical features.

Variability and Range of Motion

• Barbell Bench Press: The range of motion is somewhat fixed, and hand placement on the bar is generally standardized. This may not be ideal for individuals with shoulder issues or who need specific hand positioning for comfort.
• Dumbbell Bench Press: Dumbbells provide greater variability in hand and arm position, allowing for different grips and angles. This can be more accommodating for people with shoulder discomfort or specific preferences.

Muscle Activation

• Barbell Bench Press: It places a strong emphasis on the pectoral muscles, and the triceps and shoulders are also heavily engaged. The use of a barbell may reduce the involvement of certain stabilizer muscles.
• Dumbbell Bench Press: It activates the pectorals, triceps, and shoulders similarly to the barbell press. However, due to the independent arm movement, it may engage more stabilizer muscles, especially in the upper back and core.

Ease of Spotting

• Barbell Bench Press: It’s typically easier to spot someone during a barbell bench press because you can lift the bar off the chest if necessary.
• Dumbbell Bench Press: Spotting a dumbbell press is more challenging, and the spotter needs to assist the lifter by taking the dumbbells if needed.

Strength and Weight Lifted

• Barbell Bench Press: Generally, people can lift more weight in a barbell bench press due to the added stability and assistance of both arms.
• Dumbbell Bench Press: The independent movement of each arm can make it more challenging to lift heavier weights, which may be a consideration for those focused on pure strength gains.

The barbell bench press offers more stability and allows you to lift heavier weights, while the dumbbell bench press provides more freedom of movement and can help address muscle imbalances.

There’s not a massive difference between the two, but it’s generally a good idea to focus on one when you start off.

Target muscle

The barbell bench press and dumbbell bench press primarily target the same major muscle groups, but they may engage these muscles slightly differently due to their equipment and mechanics.

The primary target muscles for both exercises include:

• Pectoralis Major (Chest): The pectoralis major, or chest muscles, are the primary muscles worked during both the barbell and dumbbell bench press. These exercises are highly effective for chest development.
• Anterior Deltoids (Front Shoulders): Both exercises engage the anterior deltoid muscles of the shoulders.
• Triceps Brachii (Triceps): The triceps, located at the back of the upper arm, play a significant role in extending the elbow during both the barbell and dumbbell bench press.

In addition to the primary muscle groups, both exercises involve secondary muscles, including:

• Serratus Anterior: This muscle helps stabilize the shoulder blades during the pressing movement.
• Trapezius and Rhomboids: These muscles are involved in stabilizing the shoulder blades and upper back.
• Biceps: The biceps help stabilize the elbow joint and assist in controlling the weight during the lowering phase.

The differences in equipment and mechanics between the two exercises may lead to variations in muscle engagement.

For example:

• The dumbbell bench press, with its independence of arm movement, may engage stabilizer muscles more due to the need for balance and control.
• The barbell bench press, with its rigid bar, may distribute the load more evenly between both sides of the body and involve the triceps to a greater extent.

It’s important to note that individual variations in anatomy and form can also influence muscle engagement.

Both exercises are highly effective for chest development, and the choice between them often depends on individual goals, preferences, and how each exercise feels for the individual.

How to do Barbell Bench Press?

The barbell bench press is a fundamental compound exercise for building upper body strength and targeting the chest, shoulders, and triceps.

Here’s how to perform a barbell bench press correctly:

1. Set Up:
   • Place the bench in the middle of the power rack and adjust it to your desired angle (flat, incline, or decline).
   • Ensure the safety pins or catches on the rack are set at an appropriate height just above your chest in case you need to rack the bar.
   • Load the bar with the desired weight plates.
2. Lay Down:
   • Lie flat on the bench, ensuring your head, upper back, and hips are in contact with the bench. Your feet should be planted firmly on the ground.
   • Position yourself so that your eyes are directly under the barbell.
3. Grip the Bar:
   • Reach up and grip the bar with both hands slightly wider than shoulder-width apart. Your palms should be facing away from your body.
   • Your wrists should be straight, and your forearms should be perpendicular to the floor.
4. Unrack the Bar:
   • Lift the bar from the rack by straightening your arms. Hold it directly over your chest with your elbows extended.
5. Lower the Bar:
   • Take a deep breath and lower the bar in a controlled manner to your chest. The bar should touch your chest just below your nipple line.
   • Keep your elbows at about a 45-degree angle to your body; avoid flaring them out too wide.
6. Press the Bar:
   • Exhale as you push the bar back up to the starting position. Fully extend your elbows at the top of the movement.
7. Repeat:
   • Complete the desired number of repetitions. Focus on maintaining proper form and control throughout the set.
8. Rerack the Bar:
   • When you’ve finished your set, carefully return the bar to the rack, ensuring that it’s securely in place on the safety pins.

Tips for a Safe and Effective Barbell Bench Press:

• Use a spotter, especially when lifting heavy weights, to assist with unracking and racking the bar and to ensure safety during the exercise.
• Start with a weight that allows you to perform the exercise with proper form. You can gradually increase the weight as you become more experienced.
• Maintain a slight arch in your lower back to keep your chest high and shoulders back.
• Keep your core engaged and maintain a stable, planted-feet position.
• Warm up with lighter weights and progressively increase the load during your working sets.
• Focus on a controlled eccentric (lowering) and concentric (lifting) phase of the movement.
• Pay attention to your breathing, inhaling as you lower the bar and exhaling as you press it up.

Proper form is crucial for safety and effectiveness, so if you’re new to the exercise, consider working with a qualified fitness trainer to ensure you’re using correct form and technique.

When should you do Barbell Bench Press?

The timing for when to do a barbell bench press can vary based on your overall workout routine and fitness goals.

Here are some common scenarios for incorporating the barbell bench press into your training schedule:

• Chest Training Day: Many people include the barbell bench press on a dedicated chest training day. This allows you to focus on chest-specific exercises and variations to maximize chest development.
• Push Day: Some workout routines combine chest, shoulders, and triceps exercises on a “push” day. The barbell bench press can be a central exercise on push days, along with overhead presses and triceps exercises.
• Upper Body Split: If you follow a split routine where you train different muscle groups on different days, you can include the barbell bench press on an upper body or upper push day.
• Strength Training: If your primary goal is to build strength, you can include the barbell bench press in your strength training routine as one of the core compound exercises. Lift heavy weights with lower repetitions to focus on strength gains.
• Full-Body Workouts: Some full-body workout programs incorporate the barbell bench press on days that involve total body training. In these routines, you might combine the bench press with lower body and core exercises.
• Powerlifting or Bodybuilding Split: Depending on your specific training goals, you can add the barbell bench press into a powerlifting program, focusing on increasing your bench press numbers, or a bodybuilding split, emphasizing chest aesthetics.
• Periodization: Periodization involves changing your training routine periodically to avoid plateaus. You can rotate the barbell bench press in and out of your routine based on your periodization plan.
• Personal Preference: Ultimately, the timing of your barbell bench press sessions should align with your personal preference and when you feel the most energy and motivation to tackle your chest training.

Remember to allow sufficient recovery between chest workouts to avoid overtraining and promote muscle growth.

You can also incorporate accessory exercises, such as incline bench presses, to target different areas of the chest and create variety in your training routine.

It’s essential to design a workout plan that aligns with your specific goals, whether they’re focused on strength, hypertrophy, or overall fitness.

Benefits of Barbell Bench Press

The barbell bench press offers a wide range of benefits for individuals looking to build upper body strength and improve their physical fitness.

Here are some of the key benefits of the barbell bench press:

• Chest Development: The primary target of the barbell bench press is the pectoralis major, which allows for significant chest development. This exercise is crucial for building a strong and well-defined chest.
• Strength Gains: The bench press is a compound movement that engages multiple muscle groups, including the chest, shoulders, and triceps. It is one of the best exercises for building upper body strength.
• Muscle Hypertrophy: In addition to strength, the bench press can promote muscle hypertrophy (muscle growth), especially when performed with higher reps and appropriate weight progression.
• Improved Pushing Power: The strength gained from the bench press can translate into improved pushing power for other exercises and activities, both in and out of the gym.
• Enhanced Upper Body Balance: It helps in developing balanced upper body strength by engaging the shoulders and triceps alongside the chest muscles.
• Core Engagement: The bench press requires core stability to maintain proper form and control throughout the exercise, which contributes to core strength.
• Increased Bone Density: Weight-bearing exercises like the bench press can promote increased bone density, potentially reducing the risk of osteoporosis.
• Improved Posture: Strengthening the chest and upper back muscles can help improve posture by countering the effects of hunching forward.
• Injury Prevention: When performed with proper form, the bench press can help stabilize the shoulders and prevent injury by strengthening the supporting muscles.
• Variety of Training Options: The bench press can be adapted for various training goals, including strength, hypertrophy, muscular endurance, and power.

To reap these benefits and minimize the risk of injury, it’s essential to perform the barbell bench press with proper form and gradually progress in weight as your strength improves.

Cons of Barbell Bench Press

While the barbell bench press offers numerous benefits, it also has some potential drawbacks and limitations. It’s essential to be aware of the cons and take appropriate precautions when including this exercise in your fitness routine.

Here are some of the cons of the barbell bench press:

• Risk of Injury: The barbell bench press can be associated with a higher risk of injury, particularly when performed with improper form, lifting too much weight, or failing to use safety precautions.
• Overemphasis on Chest: While the barbell bench press primarily targets the chest, it can sometimes lead to an overemphasis on chest development at the expense of other muscle groups.
• Lack of Stabilization: The use of a barbell can limit the range of motion and stability in the shoulders and may not engage the stabilizer muscles as effectively as other chest exercises.
• Inability to Train Unilaterally: Unlike the dumbbell bench press, which allows independent arm movement, the barbell bench press is a bilateral exercise. This means both arms work together and can mask strength or muscle imbalances between the two sides.
• Risk of Plateaus: Over time, you may experience plateaus in strength gains with the barbell bench press if your training program does not incorporate sufficient variety or progression.
• Need for a Spotter: Lifting heavy weights on the barbell bench press often requires a spotter for safety. This can be inconvenient for solo training sessions.
• Equipment and Space: Access to a proper bench and power rack with a barbell and weights is necessary, which may not be available to everyone. The exercise may also require a significant amount of space in the gym.
• Risk of Overtraining: Overtraining can occur if you perform the barbell bench press too frequently without adequate recovery time, which can lead to burnout and decreased performance.
• Inaccessibility for Some Individuals: People with certain physical limitations or injuries may not be able to safely perform the barbell bench press, making it less accessible for a portion of the population.
• Psychological Stress: Lifting heavy weights on the bench press can induce psychological stress or performance anxiety in some individuals, which may be a barrier to consistent training.

If you are a beginner, consider consulting with a qualified fitness trainer or physical therapist to address any individual limitations or concerns.

How to do Dumbbell Bench Press?

The dumbbell bench press targets the chest, shoulders, and triceps. It offers more independence for each arm compared to the barbell bench press, which can help address muscle imbalances and provide a greater range of motion.

Here’s how to perform the dumbbell bench press correctly:

1. Set Up:
   • Place a bench in the middle of the gym with enough space on both sides.
   • Select a pair of dumbbells of an appropriate weight for your strength and fitness level.
   • Sit on the bench with your back against the bench and your feet flat on the floor.
2. Grip the Dumbbells:
   • Hold a dumbbell in each hand with a neutral grip (palms facing each other).
   • Situate the dumbbells on your thighs as you prepare to lie down.
3. Lying Down:
   • Lie back on the bench, and as you do, lift the dumbbells to shoulder level with your arms extended.
   • Your head, upper back, and hips should be in contact with the bench.
4. Starting Position:
   • Hold the dumbbells directly above your chest with your arms fully extended.
   • Your wrists should be straight, and your elbows should have a slight bend, maintaining tension in your chest and triceps.
5. Lower the Dumbbells:
   • Inhale and slowly lower the dumbbells in a controlled manner to the sides of your chest. Aim to bring the dumbbells to chest level or slightly below.
6. Press the Dumbbells:
   • Exhale as you press the dumbbells back up to the starting position, extending your arms fully. Keep your wrists straight throughout the movement.
7. Repeat:
   • Complete the desired number of repetitions, focusing on maintaining proper form and control.
8. Rack the Dumbbells:
   • After your set is complete, carefully place the dumbbells back on your thighs and use your legs to help you sit up, then return the dumbbells to the floor.

Tips for a Safe and Effective Dumbbell Bench Press:

• Start with a weight that allows you to perform the exercise with proper form. You can gradually increase the weight as your strength improves.
• Keep your core engaged and maintain a stable, planted-feet position.
• Warm up with lighter weights and progressively increase the load during your working sets.
• Focus on a controlled eccentric (lowering) and concentric (lifting) phase of the movement.
• Pay attention to your breathing, inhaling as you lower the dumbbells and exhaling as you press them up.
• If you’re new to the exercise or lifting heavy weights, it’s a good idea to have a spotter for safety.

Like the barbell bench press, proper form is crucial for safety and effectiveness, so if you’re new to the exercise, consider working with a qualified fitness trainer to ensure you’re using the correct technique.

When should you do Dumbbell Bench Press?

The timing for when to do the dumbbell bench press can vary depending on your overall workout routine, fitness goals, and training preferences.

Here are some common scenarios for incorporating the dumbbell bench press into your workout schedule:

1. Chest Training Day: Many individuals include the dumbbell bench press as a central exercise on a dedicated chest training day. This allows you to focus on chest-specific exercises and variations to maximize chest development.
2. Upper Body Split: If you follow a split routine where you train different muscle groups on different days, you can include the dumbbell bench press on an upper body or upper push day. This often combines chest, shoulders, and triceps exercises.
3. Push Day: Some workout routines combine chest, shoulders, and triceps exercises on a “push” day. The dumbbell bench press can be one of the core exercises on push days.
4. Strength Training: If your primary goal is to build strength, you can include the dumbbell bench press in your strength training routine. Lift heavy weights with lower repetitions to focus on strength gains.
5. Muscle Hypertrophy: For those aiming to build muscle mass and hypertrophy, the dumbbell bench press can be part of a bodybuilding-style split routine with higher repetitions and more volume.
6. Variation and Periodization: The dumbbell bench press can be rotated in and out of your routine as part of a periodization plan. This helps avoid plateaus and keeps your workouts fresh and challenging.
7. Full-Body Workouts: Some full-body workout programs incorporate the dumbbell bench press on days that involve total body training. In these routines, you might combine the bench press with lower body and core exercises.
8. Personal Preference: Ultimately, the timing of your dumbbell bench press sessions should align with your personal preference and when you feel the most energy and motivation for chest training.

To maximize the benefits of the dumbbell bench press and ensure balanced chest development, consider incorporating other chest exercises within your workout routine.

Additionally, allow sufficient recovery time between chest workouts to promote muscle growth and avoid overtraining.

Benefits of Dumbbell Bench Press

The dumbbell bench press is a versatile and effective upper-body exercise, offering a wide range of benefits to individuals working on their chest.

Here are some of the key benefits of the dumbbell bench press:

• Chest Development: The primary target of the dumbbell bench press is the pectoralis major, making it an excellent exercise for building a strong and well-defined chest.
• Independence for Each Arm: Unlike the barbell bench press, the dumbbell bench press offers independence for each arm. This allows you to work each side of your chest equally and address potential muscle imbalances.
• Improved Range of Motion: Dumbbells provide a greater range of motion compared to a barbell. This can lead to a fuller stretch and better muscle engagement in the chest.
• Balanced Muscle Development: By working each arm independently, the dumbbell bench press can help prevent or correct muscle imbalances, which is important for balanced muscle development.
• Core Engagement: To maintain stability during the exercise, your core muscles are engaged, leading to improved core strength.
• Enhanced Shoulder Stability: The exercise engages the stabilizer muscles of the shoulder, helping improve overall shoulder stability and reducing the risk of shoulder injuries.
• Versatility: Dumbbells are versatile and can be used for a variety of chest exercises, such as incline bench presses, decline bench presses, and flyes, to target different areas of the chest.
• Functional Strength: Developing strength in the pushing motion with the dumbbell bench press can translate to improved performance in everyday activities that require upper body strength.
• Variety in Training: The dumbbell bench press can be adapted for various training goals, including strength, hypertrophy (muscle growth), muscular endurance, and power.
• Lower Risk of Injury: The exercise may have a lower risk of certain injuries, such as shoulder strain, when compared to the barbell bench press.
• Metabolism Boost: Like other compound exercises, the dumbbell bench press elevates your heart rate and metabolism, contributing to calorie burning during and after the workout.

As with any exercise, it’s important to warm up, use proper form, and gradually increase the weight as your strength improves.

For beginners or those new to weightlifting, working with a qualified fitness trainer can help you learn proper technique and ensure a safe and effective training routine.

Cons of Dumbbell Bench Press

While the dumbbell bench press offers many benefits, it also has some potential drawbacks and limitations that you should be aware of.

Here are some of the cons of the dumbbell bench press:

• Complex Setup: The dumbbell bench press can be more time-consuming to set up compared to the barbell bench press. You need to select and position each dumbbell, which may be less convenient, especially when using heavy weights.
• Stability Challenges: The independence of each arm can introduce stability challenges, especially for beginners. Balancing and controlling the dumbbells can be more difficult than handling a barbell.
• Spotting Difficulty: Unlike the barbell bench press, spotting during the dumbbell bench press can be more challenging, especially when lifting heavy weights. It often requires a dedicated spotter to assist.
• Weight Limitations: Some gyms may have a limited range of dumbbells, which can be a drawback if you need very heavy weights for your training. This limitation can hinder your progress in terms of strength development.
• Risk of Injury: The risk of injury can be higher for those who lack proper form or control when using dumbbells, particularly if the dumbbells are dropped. Inadequate spotting can also increase the risk of injury.
• Cost: Building a home gym with a wide range of dumbbells can be costly, as you need multiple pairs of dumbbells in varying weights. Access to a gym with a complete dumbbell set is often more practical.
• Difficulty for Beginners: Beginners may find it challenging to learn proper form and control when performing the dumbbell bench press. It requires a good understanding of how to balance and coordinate the movements of both arms.
• Plateaus: While the dumbbell bench press is an effective exercise, some individuals may experience plateaus in strength gains, especially if they don’t have access to a wide range of dumbbell weights.
• Limited Access: In crowded gyms or home setups with limited space, accessing the bench and dumbbells can be challenging, leading to longer wait times or workout interruptions.
• Less Repetition Control: It can be more challenging to control the speed and depth of the repetitions with dumbbells compared to a barbell.

To mitigate these cons, it’s crucial to prioritize safety, learn proper form, and gradually progress in weight as your strength improves.

FAQs